Reply Patent Number: us-3,750,158
United States Patent  [II] 3,750,158
Anastassakis  July 31,1973
 WEIGHT SENSITIVE SECURITY SYSTEM
 Inventor: Evangelos M.Anastassakls, c/o
Maxham & Schurgin, One Boston
Place, Boston, Mass. 02108
 Filed: June 2, 1972
 Appl. No.: 259,010
 U.S. CI. …………….340/272, 177/1, 177/50,
 Int. CL. G08b 21/00, G01g 19/00, G01g 23/18
 Field of Search…………………340/272, 280;
200/85 R;177/I,245, 50; 235/91 L,92 WT;
 Referemces Cited
UNITED STATES PATENTS
2,936,163 5/1960 Foster....………… 177/245
2,919,851 1/1960 Otis.....……………235/91 L
3,447,617 6/1969 Susor.....…………… 177/3
Primary Examiner--John W. Caldwell
Assistant Examiner-- Scott F. Partridge
Attorney-Joseph Weingarten, Stanley M. Schurgin
A security system for detection of the unauthorized removal of articles from a controlled area in which the weight of an individual is determined upon entrance
into and exit from a controlled area, the difference between entrance and exit weights being employed to determine whether items arc being removed. Upon en-
trance into a controlled area, an individual's weight is determined and a coded card provided indicating the entrance weight. Upon exit from the controlled area,
the individual is again weighed and the exit weight compared with the entrance weight decoded from the card by card reading apparatus. The difference in en-
trance and exit weight is compared with a reference value and upon exceedance of the 'reference value causes an alarm indication.
在一個安全保密系統中, 以輸入埠與出口重量之間的差异決定一個受控制的區域結束或使用.在移入一個受控制的區域的輸入埠上，單獨的重量被確定，並且提供的表明輸入埠重量一張編碼的卡片。 在上結束受控制的區域，個體再一次透過卡片讀物儀器稱重量，並且與從卡片破譯的輸入埠重量相比的出口重量。 在輸入埠和出口重量的區別與參考價值比較和超過‘參考價值造成警報指示。
Reply By Zhen-man Lin
Anastassakis,( US Pat. No.3,750,158 ) patent, takes weight as the parameter to compare the difference resulting from the preset value. If the difference exceeds the predetermined range, an alarm will occur or another region will be controlled. The patent mainly involves “the comparative unit of digital weight”, which is “IC” component available everywhere. Does that mean that we can use the patent of 3,750,158 if the unit is available?
Therefore, the patent of 3,750,158 does not affect the patent of Zhen-Man Lin, which uses digitized weight as another check means. The key of Zhen-Man Lin’s patent is “system”, and it is allowed to involve related patent in a huge anti-hijacking system.
Anastassakis, us-3,750,158 的專利重點是以重量作為參數去比較原設定值所造成了一個差別，假如該差別超越所預定的比較范圍，便會產生警報指示或去控制其它的區域，專利重點涉及的是“數碼重量的比較單元”，而這個“數碼重量的比較單元”正是到處可以買到的“IC”電子零件，也就是說買到這種“數碼重量比較單元”的“IC”，是否可以說便已經擁有了3,750,158 的專利重點的使用權？
因比3,750,158 的專利并不能影響林哲民專利中以數碼化的重量的比較結果去增加識別人員手段的參數，Zhen-Man Lin專利中的重點是“系統”，在一個龐大的防劫機系統的工程應用中的零配件涉及相關專利是允許的。
9 Claims, 4 Drawing Figures
WEIGHT SENSITIVE SECURITY SYSTEM
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
This invention relates to security systems and more particularly to a system for the detection of the unauthorized removal of articles from a controlled area by use of weight comparison techniques.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Security systems are known for the prevention of theft or unauthorized removal of articles from stores, libraries and other areas to be controlled. In many such systems, sensible tags are placed upon items m be protected and the presence of such a tag at a sensing station at or near a store exit is employed to cause alarm actuation, it is an object of the present invention to provide a security system in which individual items within a store or other protected area need not be tagged or otherwise marked and in which the weight of an individual entering and leaving a protected area is employed to determine unauthorized article removal.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In accordance with the invention, the weight of an individual entering and leaving a protected or controlled area is determined and a difference between entrance and exit weights computed, this difference weight being compared with a reference value to provide a system output indication. The detection of a difference between entrance and exit weight which exceeds a predetermined reference value serves as an indication that an article is leaving the controlled area which was not with the individual upon his entrance into this area. Such detection causes the actuation of a suitable alarm indication and can also cause the locking of exit doors, if the difference between entrance and exit weights is within the tolerance provided by the system the person leaves the controlled area unimpeded.
Briefly, the invention comprises a controlled entrance to an area being protected, a platform scale or other suitable weighing means operative to determine the entrance weight of an individual and to issue a machine readable card bearing a representation of the measured entrance weight. At a controlled exit, the individual is again weighed such as by a platform scale and the entrance weight card inserted into a card reader operative to decode the weight recorded thereon and to cause comparison of this entrance weight with the exit weight determined at the exit station. The weight difference between entrance and exit weights is determined by associated logic circuitry and is compared in the logic with a reference value selected in accordance with predetermined system tolerance requirements. Upon exceedance of the reference value by the computed weight difference, an output indication is provided for the actuation of suitable alarms and if desired for the automatic locking of exit doors.
DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The invention will be more fully understood from the following detailed description taken in conjunction with the nccompanyin8 drawings in which:
FIG. I is a diagrammatic representation of entrance apparatus of a system embodying the invention;
FIG. 2 is a diagrammatic representation of exit apparatus of a system embodying the invention;
FIG. 3 is a block diagram representation of the signal processing circuitry of the embodiment of FIG. 2; and
FIG. 4 is a block diagram representation of an alternative embodiment of the signal processing circuitry of the invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The apparatus of the invention provided at an entrance to an area to be protected is depicted in FIG. 1 and includes a scale 10 having a scale platform 12 disposed at a controlled entrance through which individuals must pass to gain entrance into the controlled or protected area A door or other suitable barrier 14 is provided at the entrance end of the scale platform 12, while a second door or other barrier 16 is provided at the exit end of scale platform 12. In typical embodiment, the entrance door 14 can be manually opened to enter the scale platform. A light source 18 is disposed in a position between door 14 and platform 12 and is operative to direct a light beam onto an associated photosensor 20 which is coupled to an indicator 22 and a door control 24. Another light source 26 is disposed between the platform 12 and door 16 and is operative to direct a light beam onto an associated photosensor 28 which is also coupled to door control 24 and to an indicator 30.
In operation, a person enters through door 14 onto the scale platform 12 and in so doing passes through the light beam from light source 18, causing photosensor 20 m provide a signal to indicator 22, the actuation of which indicates the presence of a person on platform 12. The signal from photosensor 20 is also applied to door control 24 which can cause the latching of both doors 14 and 16. Latching of door 14 prevents the exiting of a person from that door once he has entered the controlled area and aim will prevent the entry of a second person onto the scale platform 12 while a person is being weighed. The latching of door 16 will cause the individual to remain on the scale platform for a time sufficient to obtain his weight. The weight determined by the scale 10 is imprinted or otherwise marked on a card or ticket 11 which is dispensed to the individual by card dispensing apparatus 13, The card contains the weight in any suitable machine readable form, such as optically or magnetically sensible characters or in coded form such as punched holes or sensible marks.
Upon removal of the coded card from the dispenser 13 associated with scale 10, an enabling signal is provided to door control 24, and upon traversal by the individual of the light beam from light source 26, causing photosensor 28 to provide a signal to door control 24, the doors 14 and 16 are caused to be opened or unlocked to allow the egress of the person from the entrance area into the protected area and the entrance of another person onto the scale platform. The output signals from photosensors 20 and 28 can also be coupled to a counter 'circuit 32 which provides a talley of the number of individuals entering the protected area and a talley of the number of individuals leaving the protected area. An indicator 30 can also be energized by the photosenaor 28 to provide an output indication that an individual has left the entrance zone into the protected area.
The portion of the system provided at the exit zone of a protected area is depicted in FIG. 2 in the context of a supermarket or other serf-service store at which merchandise is placed upon a checkout counter for payment and subsequent packaging. At the exit zone as shown in FIG. 2 a scale 34 and an associated scale plat-form 36 are provided with an entrance door 38 on one side of platform 36 and an exit door 40 on the opposite side thereof. A light source 42 is provided between door 38 and platform 36 for directing a light beam onto photosensor 44 and which, in turn, is operative to provide a signal to an associated indicator 46 and a door control 48. A light source 50 is disposed outside of door 40 and is arranged to direct a light beam onto photosensor 52 which is operative to provide an output signal to an indicator 54 and to door control 48. The photosensors 44 and 52 also apply an output signal to counter circuit 32. A merchandise counter 56 is disposed adjacent platform 36 and includes an area 58 in front of door 38 at which merchandise is deposited for checkout. A checkout attendant is stationed at a cash register 60 disposed centrally of counter 56 to check out items deposited thereon. An area 62 of counter 56 disposed outside of door 40 is provided for deposit of checked out merchandise which can then be removed by an individual leaving the protected area.
In passing through the exit zone, an individual enters via door 38 onto scale platform 36 and inserts the coded weight card into a card reader 33 which is associated with scale 34. Upon passage by the individual through the light beam from light source 42, the photosensor 44 provides a signal to door control 48 which locks doors 38 and 40 to prevent the entrance of more than one individual onto platform 36 and to prevent the exit by the individual present on the scale platform until after the weight comparison procedure is complete. Scale 34 is operative to determine the exit weight of the individual on platform 36 and to provide an output indication of this exit weight to logic 64 which also receives, from card reader 33, a representation of the entrance weight provided on the card dispensed to the individual at the entrance station.
The weight difference is employed to denote whether items are lacing removed from the controlled area. The added exit weight caused for example by the presence of a purloined article on an individual is detected at the exit zone and utilized by logic 64 to cause alarm actuation. The embodiment described does not provide an alarm condition if the exit weight is less than the entrance weight, such as could occur if an individual leaves a package in the controlled area; however, the system logic can be arranged to produce an output indication in this event to signal the possiblity that an item entering with a person into the area being protected has been left in this area.
The logic 64 is shown in FIG. 3 and includes a difference circuit 66 which receives as a first input the exit weight provided by scale 34 and as a second input the entrance weight decoded by the card reader 31.3 from the entrance weight card. The coded entrance weight is typically decoded in digital form and by means of a digital-to-analog converter 68, converted to analog form for application to the difference circuit, it will be appreciated that the weight determinations can be provided in either analog or digital form with the difference circuit operative accordingly. The output of difference circuit 66 is a signal representative of the algebraic difference between the entrance and exit weights, labeled A W and equal to Wout-W(n), and which is applied as one input to a comparator 70. The other input to the comparator is a reference signal provided by a reference source 72. This reference signal specifies the maximum weigh difference tolerable in a particular system installation. Two output signals are provided by comparator 70 depending upon whether the measured weight difference between the exit and entrance weights is less 'than or greater than the reference value.
In the event that the weight difference is within the system tolerance range, that is, the weight difference is less than the reference level provided by reference source 72, comparator 70 is operative to provide an output signal to door control circuitry 48 to open or unlock door 40 and permit the exit of an individual from the controlled area. Door control circuitry 48 can also be operative to open or unlock door 38 to permit entry of another person onto platform 36. In the event that the weight difference is greater than the reference level, comparator 70 is operative to provide an outut signal to alarm circuitry 74 which can include a suitable alarm indicator. In this latter event, the exit door 40 normally will remain locked to prevent the egress of an individual until the cause of the excessive weight differencc is ascertained.
In an alternative embodiment of the invention, the entrance and exit weight determinations can be provided by respective scales 10 and 34 to data storage registers or other suitable means for retaining a representation of the entrance and exit weights for difference computation without use of a coded weight card. Referring to FIG. 4, signals representative of the entrance and exit weights provided respectively by scales 10 and 34 are applied to respective data storage registers 78 and 80, the output of the respective registers being applied to difference circuit d4L User identification apparatus 82 fend 84 is provided at respective entrance and exit zones to provide output indications of the identity of a person and which are employed to associate the entrance and exit weights of the identified individual for subsequent weight comparison. Such apparatus is per se well known and can be an identification card reader or a keyboard for manual entry of an identity code. The output signal from difference circuit 66 represents the weight difference which is then applied to comparator 70 for further processing as described above.
It will be appreciated that the invention can be implemented in different ways to suit specific operating requirements, and it is not intended to limit the invention by what has been particularly shown and described. It should be evident that the invention finds application in a variety of environments in which an area is to be protected from unauthorized article removal, for exampie in libraries, museums and stores.
What is claimed is:
1. A security system comprising:
means for determining the weight of an individual upon entry into a controlled area;
means for providing a first signal representative of said entrance weight;
means for determining the weight of said individual upon exit from said controlled area;
means for providing a second signal representative of said exit weight;
means operative in response to said first and second signals for providing an output signal representing the difference therebetween;
means for providing a reference signal representative of a maximum allowable weight difference between said entrance and exit weights; and
means operative in response to said reference signal and said output signal for providing an alarm indication in the event that said output signal represents a weight difference greater than that represented by said reference signal.
2. A security system according to claim I wherein:
said entrance weight determining means includes a scale having a platform on which an individual is disposed for weighing, and means for providing a coded card having a sensible representation of the entrance weight thereon;
said exit weight providing means includes a scale having a platform on which an individual is disposed for weighing; and
said first signal providing means includes means at the exit from said controlled area for reading said coded card and for providing said first signal representative of the entrance weight encoded thereon.
3. A security system according to claim I including:
an entrance zone at which said entrance weight is determined, an exit zone at which said exit weight is determined, and an entrance and exit barrier for each of said zones;
means at each of said zones for detecting the entry of an individual therein and the exit of an indivudal therefrom;
means operative upon detection of the presence of an individual in said entrance zone for locking said entrance barrier to prevent entry of another individual while one individual is already present, and for locking said exit barrier to prevent the egress of said individual into said entrance zone until his weight has been determined; and
means operative upon of the presence of an indium m said exit zone for locking the entrance barrier thereof to prevent entry of another individual until the individual in said exit zone lure left said zone, and for locking the exit barrier of said exit zone to prevent egress of the individual m said exit zone in response to an output signal representing a weight difference greater than said maximum allowable difference.
4. A security system according to claim I including:
means for storing representations of the corresponding entrance and exit weights of an individual; and
means operative to provide said first and second signals in response to said stored representations.
5, A security system comprising:
an entrance zone through which individuals must pass for entry into a controlled area, said zone including:
means for determining the weight of an individual upon entry into said controlled area;
means for providing to said individual a coded card having a sensible representation of said entrance weight thereon;
an exit zone through which individuals in said controlled area must pass in leaving said controlled area, said exit zone including:
means for determining the weight of an individual upon exit from said controlled area;
means for providing a first signal representative of said exit weight;
means for sensing said coded card and for providing a second signal representative of the entrance weight decoded therefrom;
means operative in response to said first and second signals for providing an output signal representing the difference therebetween:
means for providing a reference signal representative of a maximum allowable weight difference between said entrance and exit weights; and
means operative in response to said reference signal and said output signall for providing an alarm indication in the event that said output signal represents a weight difference greater than that represented by said reference signal.
6. A security system according to claim 5 wherein said entrance and exit zones each include:
a selectively operable entrance and exit barrier disposed at respective entry and exit positions of said zone;
means for detecting the entry of an individual into said zone and for providing a detection signal in response thereto;
means for detecting the exit of an individual from said zone and for providing a detection signal in response thereto: and
control means operative in response to said detection signals for selectively locking and unlocking said entrance and exit barriers.
7. A security system according to claim 5 wherein said means operative in response to said first and second signals includes a difference circuit operative to provide an output signal having a magnitude representing the difference between the magnitudes of said first and second signals;
and wherein said reference signal responsive means includes a comparator circuit receiving said reference signal and said output signal and operative to provide an alarm signal in the event that said output signal is of a magnitude representing a weight difference greater than that represented by the magnitude of said reference signal.
8. A security system a,cording to claim 7 including counting means operative in response to the presence of each individual at said entrance and exit zones to provide an indication of the number of individuals entering and leaving said controlled area.
9. A security system according to claim 7 wherein said weight determining means each includes a scale having a platform on which an individual is disposed for weighing.